Looks: The bar on the box appears to be taller than the real bar. Other than that (and the fact that I couldn’t bite into it without cracking all of the surrounding chocolate), it is accurately advertised. 4 out of 5

Taste: Very good – I enjoyed this bar much more than a regular Klondike bar, and the only difference is the Heath bits in the chocolate shell. The ice cream is creamy, the chocolate shell isn’t too thick, and the toffee breaks up the monotony of the chocolate/ice cream combo (if you could call such a partnership monotonous). The only beef I have with this bar is that I think it’s about 30% too big – when I get two-thirds of the way through, I feel like I should be done, but there’s still four or five more bites to go. 4 out of 5